General union of palestinian journalists in the UK

Sinai is a Red Line… Not Every Bird Can Be Eaten… And the Egyptian Army Is No Ordinary Army

Sinai is a Red Line… Not Every Bird Can Be Eaten… And the Egyptian Army Is No Ordinary Army

Sinai is a Red Line… Not Every Bird Can Be Eaten… And the Egyptian Army Is No Ordinary Army
By Dr. Ibrahim Asaliya
Journalist and University Lecturer in Media Ethics (London)

The statements made by Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich regarding Sinai are not merely a passing remark in a political debate—especially when the subject is Egyptian territory inextricably linked in Arab and Egyptian memory to the October War and long years of conflict and sacrifice.

When an Israeli official claims that “Sinai will cease to exist” should Egypt attack Israel, the natural question arises: what drives an Israeli government official to drag Sinai into such threatening rhetoric in the first place?

Sinai is a red line.

This is not just a political slogan; it is a fact rooted in Egyptian sovereignty and the region’s modern history. Sinai returned to Egyptian sovereignty following the October War and a protracted political process, becoming an integral part of Egyptian territory.

Consequently, any talk of targeting or encroaching upon Sinai cannot be divorced from the delicate nature of Egyptian-Israeli relations or the profound significance Sinai holds in the Egyptian consciousness.

Most importantly, anyone speaking about Sinai must remember that Egypt is a nation with a rich military history; its armed forces have waged major wars to defend their land, and the Egyptian army was a pivotal force in the October War—a conflict that fundamentally altered the regional equation.

Not every bird can be eaten.

The message here is not a call to war, but a reminder that the language of threats—when directed at the territory of a sovereign state—can carry repercussions that extend far beyond the person making the statement. Egypt and Israel have been bound by a peace treaty since 1979, and the stability of this relationship serves both regional and international interests. Consequently, rhetoric that frames Sinai as a source of threat does nothing to safeguard this stability; instead, it raises grave questions regarding the future of security in the region.

As for the Egyptian military, it is an institution with a long history and vast accumulated experience; it cannot simply be treated as a mere statistic in the calculus of regional power dynamics.

The Egyptian military is no ordinary army, and Sinai is no ordinary territory.

Anyone familiar with the region’s history knows that when it comes to its land and sovereignty, Egypt speaks a different language—the language of a nation that paid a heavy price to reclaim its territory and subsequently chose peace once it became a viable option.

Therefore, the best course of action is to keep Sinai removed from the rhetoric of threats and escalation, to respect Egypt’s sovereignty and borders, and for all parties to recognize that the stability achieved after decades of conflict is not a political game to be trifled with through a mere statement or tweet.

Sinai is a red line; and anyone who approaches such red lines must first understand their history, their rightful owners, and those who stood firm in their defense.

‏التاريخ 6-10-2026

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *